Does not work with HABTM relationships

[manzapanza]

I have a standard habtm config.
House habtm Property, with the table houses_properties and without the model HouseProperty.

On House model:
public $actsAs = array('AuditLog.Auditable' => array('Property'));

But when I change the house id = 20 changing only an association of a property in the table audits not recorded any changes!

[robwilkerson]

@manzapanza -- My apologies. I haven't been getting notified of issues or pull requests so I'm playing catch up having just noticed the activity. It looks like your config might be wrong. Try:

public $actsAs = array('AuditLog.Auditable' => array('habtm' => array('Property')));

[manzapanza]

@robwilkerson Thank you for your reply! I'm tested your suggestion but seems that don't work...
I'm showing my configs:

House.php:

public $actsAs = array('AuditLog.Auditable' => array('habtm' => array('Property')));

Property.php:

public $actsAs = array('Tree', 'AuditLog.Auditable');

View/Houses/admin_edit.ctp:

echo $this->Form->create('House');
echo $this->Form->input('id');
...
echo $this->Form->input("Property", array('multiple' => 'checkbox', 'options' => $propertyOptions, 'size' => 50, 'label' => __d('House', 'Properties')));
...

HousesController.php / function admin_edit

This is the $this->request->data :
Array
(
    [House] => Array
        (
            [id] => 132
            [name] => House name
            .......
        )
    [Property] => Array
        (
            [Property] => Array
                (
                    [0] => 96
                    [1] => 94
                    [2] => 93
                    ......
                )
        )
)
$this->House->saveAll($this->request->data);

When change House data's the Json_object stored on audits table is without Property datas. like this:

stdClass Object
(
    [House] => stdClass Object
        (
            [id] => 132
            [name] => House name 2
            .....
        )
)

[robwilkerson]

Take a look at the readme. Specifically, this line in the habtm option description:

If the HABTM model is auditable in its own right, don't include it here.

It looks like that's what you're trying to do. Am I reading your code wrong?

[manzapanza]

Honestly I did not understand this sentence, especially "don't include it here".
I try to explain better my config:
House habtm Property, this means that I have also a table houses_property without the model HouseProperty.
This mean that when edit an house i could made changes on tables houses and houses_property.
For this I thought that setting array('habtm' => array('Property')) on House model the behaviour start tracking changes on houses_property about the house edited.
Property have also auditable behaviour attached but is for tracking changes only on properties table.

[robwilkerson]

I don't remember the details now, but there were issues auditing both the relationship data (houses_property) and the other side of the relationship (Property) so I did something to prevent that conflict from happening. I don't recall the specifics at this point, but I'll take a look. Are you working in 1.3 or 2.x? It may cease to be an issue in 2.x.

[manzapanza]

I'm working in 2.x

[angelxmoreno]

@manzapanza could you try public $actsAs = array('AuditLog.Auditable'); in your House model to see if both House and Property work fine?

[ravage84]

@xhs345 close due to inactivity?
The code has changed quite a bit since then, but I havent' tested it for that case.

[xhs345]

I think having a test case for HABTM would be good before closing this issue

[ravage84]

True!